Cowling (1933): The Magnetic Field of Sunspots
T. G. Cowling's landmark 1933 paper proving that a steady axisymmetric magnetic field cannot be maintained by fluid motions alone—the first antidynamo theorem.
Published in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society in November 1933, Thomas George Cowling’s paper The Magnetic Field of Sunspots established the first rigorous no-go theorem in magnetohydrodynamics: Cowling’s antidynamo theorem.
Mathematical Argument
$$\mathbf{B} = \nabla \times (A(s,z)\,\hat{\boldsymbol{\phi}}) + B_\phi(s,z)\,\hat{\boldsymbol{\phi}}$$At any neutral ring ($O$-type closed field-line loop) where the poloidal field $\mathbf{B}_p = 0$ and the flux function $A$ attains a local extremum:
- The advective term $\mathbf{u}\times\mathbf{B}_p$ vanishes identically on the neutral ring.
- The azimuthal induction equation reduces to $\eta \nabla^2 A = 0$ (with $\eta = (\mu_0 \sigma)^{-1}$), which cannot balance the non-zero resistive diffusion ($\nabla \times \mathbf{B}_p \neq 0$) at an extremum of $A$.
Therefore, no steady (or time-dependent) axisymmetric magnetic field can be maintained by self-excited dynamo action.
Scientific Legacy
Cowling’s theorem redirected dynamo theory away from simple 2D/axisymmetric models toward genuinely three-dimensional, non-axisymmetric flows—paving the way for Elsässer’s toroidal-poloidal feedback, Parker’s cyclonic convection (1955), and the Backus (1958) and Herzenberg (1958) existence proofs.
References
- Cowling, T. G. (1933). The magnetic field of sunspots. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 94(1), 39–48. doi:10.1093/mnras/94.1.39
- Larmor, J. (1919). How could a rotating body such as the Sun become a magnet? Report of the British Association for the Advancement of Science 1919, 159–160.
- Zeldovich, Ya. B. (1956). The magnetic field in the two-dimensional motion of a conducting turbulent fluid. Soviet Physics JETP 4, 460–462 (Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz. 31, 154–156).